The rower says 640 calories. Apple Health, after you save an Indoor Row, says something else — or it has no rowing workout at all, only whatever your watch made of your arm motion. Both problems are common, and they are not the same problem.
This guide explains why rowing-machine calories are only an estimate, how a session can reach Apple Health, and where Concept2 and FTMS rowers differ. We will be direct about what we have and have not tested.
Why the console calories are not a fact
A rower cannot measure the energy you actually expended. It estimates calories from time, stroke rate, power (if it has it) and a formula that may or may not use your body weight. Two machines, or two apps, will often disagree on the same 20 minutes.
Apple Health then applies its own rules when a workout is saved, and the Fitness rings use Active Energy, not whatever number was on the console. If you compare the two and they don’t match, that is expected more often than not. Treat the console figure as a rough output, not as a calorie receipt.
Heart rate, if it is real, is a better intensity signal than the calorie total. Pair a Bluetooth chest strap or armband rather than trusting a machine value. We have seen a commercial elliptical report 0 bpm for a whole session when no strap was paired; see why machine heart rate is often wrong.
Concept2, and why it may not show up in an FTMS app
Concept2’s PM5 monitor has traditionally used Concept2’s own Bluetooth protocol, not FTMS. The usual way to get a PM5 session into Apple Health is still Concept2’s ErgData app, which also talks to the Concept2 logbook.
An FTMS app may not see a PM5 at all. If yours connects, please tell us. We have not confirmed that, and we do not want to list Concept2 as compatible until someone records a real session.
FTMS rowers, and our honest status
Many newer magnetic and water rowers, including some budget home ergs, advertise Bluetooth FTMS. In principle an FTMS app can read stroke rate, power, distance and time, then save the session to Apple Health as a rowing workout.
CadenceLink has a rower parser that follows the Bluetooth FTMS specification, with unit and fuzz tests. That is not the same as a test on a real erg. We have not confirmed CadenceLink on a real FTMS rower. The only machine we have confirmed on hardware is the Vision Fitness S60 elliptical.
If you have a rower with Bluetooth FTMS and ten minutes to spare, the most useful thing you can do is try it and write to admin@chadava.com with the make, model, what appeared, and a screenshot of the machine details card. We will add confirmed machines to the compatibility list.
How to try an FTMS log
- Wake the monitor. Close the brand app or ErgData if it is already connected.
- Open CadenceLink and look under Nearby. Tap the rower if it appears.
- Row a short piece and compare stroke rate, distance and time with the monitor.
- Save the session, then save it to Apple Health. It should be filed as a rowing workout.
If nothing appears, use the brand app if it writes to Health, or log the piece by hand from the monitor before it resets. That still beats losing the session.
Frequently asked questions
Which calorie number will show up in Apple Health? If the machine sent energy and you save the session, CadenceLink can pass that value through. Health and the Fitness rings may still present Active Energy differently. We have not verified this end to end on a real rower yet.
Do I need ErgData as well? For a Concept2 PM5, ErgData is still the proven path. You usually cannot connect two apps at once.
Can CadenceLink control the damper or resistance? No. It only reads. Set the damper and intensity on the machine.
The short version
Console calories are an estimate, and they often will not match Health. For a Concept2 PM5, start with ErgData. For an FTMS rower, a logging app can in principle save stroke rate, power and distance to Apple Health — and we would rather hear from you than pretend we have already rowed on your machine.
Get CadenceLink: Gym Cardio Log on the App Store.